When I first stepped into the world of golf footwear, I thought choosing a golf shoe would be simple. Little did I know that I would be thrown into one of the oldest debates in golf: spiked vs spikeless. And trust me—once I understood the difference, it completely changed how I played.
Whether you're a newcomer or someone looking to upgrade their gear, let me break down the real differences from the perspective of a golfer who has tried, tested, and lived through both types on the course.
What Are Spiked Golf Shoes?
When I first wore spiked shoes, I could instantly feel the grip.
Spiked shoes have replaceable cleats attached to the outsole, designed to dig into the turf and give you maximum traction.
What I Love About Spiked Shoes
-
Unmatched stability during my swing—especially when I try to generate more power.
-
Great control on wet, soft, or uneven courses.
-
Longer lifespan, since you can replace the spikes when they wear out.
Where They’re Not My First Choice
-
They can feel slightly heavier.
-
Not the best for walking long distances.
-
They’re strictly for the course—you can’t wear them casually.
What Are Spikeless Golf Shoes?
My first pair of spikeless shoes surprised me with how comfortable they felt.
These shoes rely on rubber lugs and patterns on the outsole instead of actual cleats. Think of them as a blend between a sneaker and a golf shoe.
What I Enjoy About Spikeless Shoes
-
Lightweight and incredibly comfortable, especially for walking-based rounds.
-
Versatile—I’ve worn mine straight from the course to a café without looking out of place.
-
Perfect for dry, firm courses where you don’t need too much traction.
Where They Fall Short
-
Not as strong in wet or muddy conditions.
-
Outsoles wear out faster since the grip is not replaceable.
-
They don’t provide the same locked-in feel for aggressive swingers.
Traction: The Real Difference You Feel
For me, the biggest difference between spiked and spikeless shoes is how they behave during the swing.
Spiked = Maximum Ground Grip
If you’re someone who loads the ground heavily with your legs, or if you play in wet conditions, spiked shoes will give you the solid base you need.
Spikeless = Stable Enough, but More Comfortable
On dry days where the course is firm, I’ve noticed that spikeless shoes provide more than enough traction for a smooth, controlled swing.
Comfort: The Hidden Winner
When it comes to pure comfort, spikeless wins every time for me.
If I know I’ll be walking 18 holes, I usually reach for spikeless.
But when the weather looks unpredictable?
I don’t even think twice—the spiked pair comes out.
Durability and Maintenance
Spiked Shoes
-
Spikes can be replaced
-
Outsoles last longer
-
More cost-effective over time
Spikeless Shoes
-
Once the lugs wear out, that’s it
-
Outsoles tend to wear faster
-
Great for frequent practice sessions but may need replacing sooner
I personally keep both because they serve different purposes.
Who Should Choose Spiked Shoes?
Based on my experience, go for spiked if:
-
Your swing is powerful or fast
-
You play in wet, hilly, or soft conditions
-
You want maximum balance and traction
-
You play competitive or technical rounds
These shoes are built for performance-first players.
Who Should Choose Spikeless Shoes?
Choose spikeless if:
-
You prefer comfort above everything
-
You walk the course often
-
You play mostly in dry, firm conditions
-
You want shoes you can wear casually too
-
You’re a beginner easing into the sport
These shoes blend lifestyle and golf beautifully.
My Honest Recommendation: Own One of Each
After years of switching back and forth, here’s what I’ve learned:
There’s no “better” shoe—there’s only the right shoe for the right round.
I keep:
-
A spiked pair for tournaments, wet mornings, and power-focused practice sessions.
-
A spikeless pair for casual games, long walks, and dry-weather rounds.
It’s the perfect balance between performance and comfort.
Final Thoughts
Understanding the difference between spiked and spikeless shoes completely changed how I choose footwear—and ultimately how I play my rounds.
